Diversity Discussions: Gender pay disparity in the finance industry
The finance industry has made some small strides to improve the gender pay disparity over the past five years, but there is still a long way to go. We have already talked about the rise of female talent in the private equity market. But private equity is only a small part of finance, what about the wider financial services market and those in commercial finance functions?
The Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) latest report on the state of gender diversity disclosed that:
- There is greater gender diversity in firms that are larger, but less in customer-facing roles
- The number of organisations with female senior managers has grown rapidly since 2005
- There is a wide variation across firms with gender diversity at management level ranging from less than 5% to over 40%
- Large investment management institutions have more gender diversity at senior management level; by contrast, institutional brokerage is the least gender diverse subsector
Gender pay gap or equal pay?
The gender pay gap is different from equal pay. Equal pay is about a man and a woman receiving equal pay for the same or similar job. Fundamentally, people should be paid equally for doing equivalent jobs across all businesses.
The gender pay gap is calculated as the difference between average hourly earnings of people as a proportion of men’s average hourly earnings. It is a measure across all jobs in the UK, not of the difference in pay between men and women for doing the same job.
To this backdrop, we have reviewed the last twelve months of finance placements across the UK to discover how prevalent and persistent gender pay disparity is across finance and accountancy.
Our candidates and the gender pay gap
It goes without saying, that we always want to achieve the best compensation package possible for all our candidates. But how do some of the core finance roles stand up under the glare of gender equality?
Management Accountant
- Average Management Accountant salary in the UK is £37,755
- Male Management Accountants candidates achieved an average salary of £38,714
- By comparison, female Management Accountants achieved an average salary of £36,212
This is an annual difference of £2,502. Which means male Management Accountants are paid 6.7% more than their female counterparts.
Assistant Management Accountant / Assistant Accountant
At the more junior end of the scale, we can reveal that the average Assistant Management Accountant achieved a salary of £27,809. However, unlike Management Accountants who tend to have either completed their accountancy qualifications or are nearing completion, we can reveal that:
- Male Assistant Management Accountants achieved an average salary of £26,592
- Women achieved an average salary of £29,027
This means women we place in these roles are earning 8.8% (£2,435) more than their male counterparts.
Chief Financial Officer
At the very top of the finance food chain, we have the CFO. According to our internal data, the average CFO achieved a base salary of £152,282. However, less that 5% of the CFOs we placed in 2022 were women.
Finance Director
In terms of other senior finance roles, we placed double the number of women in FD roles compared to men, but how do their salaries compare?
- Men on average £121,666
Women on average £98,800
Reviewing our data, 30% of the female FDs we placed last year achieved a basic salary of over £100,000, compared to 66% of men.
Finance Manager
- Our internal data achieve an average basic salary of £53,841. In terms of the gender gap, we can reveal that:
- Male Finance Managers achieve an average salary of £55,960
Whereas women achieve average of £51,407
This means that men earn £4,553 (8.5%) more than women in comparable Finance Manager roles.
What does this mean?
It is clear from these numbers that there is a long way to go to ensure that both genders are paid equitably for similar work. Moreover, whilst it is heartening that women are achieving more than men in certain roles, there is a gender imbalance in terms of the number of women breaking into the industry.
So, whilst it is great that in some sections of the finance discipline women are achieving higher average salaries than men, there are fewer women at the senior end breaking through into CFO and FD roles. However, even if we were to achieve gender balance at all levels, will the real battle for equal pay will get underway.
So, what can we do as talent consultants to close the inequality in gender pay in finance?
Asking about salary
Firstly, we can flip the salary question, instead of asking candidates about their current salary, we should ask them about their salary expectations and work towards achieving the uplift they want. Salary conversations should always be based on experience, ability, and skills. A women’s age, marital status or motherhood should not be a barrier to achieving an equal salary.
At Marks Sattin, we believe that to truly champion women’s rights in the workplace we must break down systemic barriers and taboos by focusing salary conversations on ability. A recruiter's negotiations for a candidate’s new opportunity are the first step in breaking a cycle which has allowed the gender pay gap to reinforce the glass ceiling.
Anonymised CV screening
Whilst many businesses claim to be impartial, including personal details such as gender, name, age, and location on a CV can influence hiring manager’s first impressions of recommended candidates. Recruitment consultants can hold back these details to ensure every applicant is judged purely on their skills and experience.
Lead from the front
However, true change comes from within. It is essential that recruitment consultancies, led by example and pay all employees fairly– no matter their gender. This allows us to educate clients and prove the positive impact of closing the gender pay gap.
In 2022, we launched our Let's Get Even campaign. The goal of this campaign was to ensure our business achieved gender balance in the work force and at management level. A key by-product of this is that our gender pay gap is naturally closing. In January 2022, only 32% of our workforce was formed of women, by December it was 49%, and our highest earner for 2022 was female. We are also actively training and promoting talented women to management and senior management level.
We are also about to kick off a specific women’s leadership programme and we recognise that men are essential in championing this and we will be doing sessions to educate them on allyship.
How we are helping support closing the gender pay gap
Organisations partner with Marks Sattin not only to tap into the ability we have built over the last 30 years but also because of our commitment to diversity and inclusion.
It is more difficult than ever to attract the best finance talent, and that challenge is only exemplified when trying to recruit diverse talent. This is where we step in. As specialists in finance recruitment, we have grown an extensive network of clients who trust us to help them build a diverse team.
If you are looking to hire for your within your finance team, we have you covered from PQ level right up to CFO, then submit a brief and we will be in touch for a chat.
Signup to receive the latest discipline specific articles
Related jobs
Salary:
£500 - £550 per day + Outside IR35
Location:
Birmingham, West Midlands
Industry
Business Services
Qualification
Fully qualified
Market
Commerce & Industry
Salary
£350 - £450
Job Discipline
Qualified Finance
Contract Type:
Contract
Description
Marks Sattin is partnering with a large organisation in the Midlands to recruit an Interim FP&A Consultant within their Finance Transformation team.
Reference
BBBH183614
Expiry Date
01/01/01
Author
Anthony MillsAuthor
Anthony MillsSalary:
£50,000 - £55,000 per annum
Location:
Leeds, West Yorkshire
Industry
Business Services
Qualification
Finalist / Newly qualified
Market
Commerce & Industry
Salary
£50,000 - £60,000
Job Discipline
Newly Qualified Finance
Contract Type:
Permanent
Description
I am delighted to be partnering with a leading UK-based business to find a Senior Accountant to join their dynamic finance team in Leeds!
Reference
18359020
Expiry Date
01/01/01
Author
Laura GunbyAuthor
Laura GunbySalary:
£50,000 - £60,000 per annum
Location:
Leeds, West Yorkshire
Industry
Business Services
Qualification
Finalist / Newly qualified
Market
Commerce & Industry
Salary
£60,000 - £70,000
Job Discipline
Newly Qualified Finance
Contract Type:
Permanent
Description
I am delighted to be working in partnership with a large business in Holbeck to recruit for a newly created Management Accountant role.
Reference
56263263
Expiry Date
01/01/01
Author
Laura GunbyAuthor
Laura GunbySalary:
£60,000 - £70,000 per annum + 15% Bonus
Location:
Uxbridge, London
Industry
Consumer & Retail
Qualification
Fully qualified
Market
Commerce & Industry
Salary
£70,000 - £80,000
Job Discipline
Qualified Finance
Contract Type:
Permanent
Description
Group Accountant - Uxbridge (Hybrid) - £60,000 to £70,000 + 15% bonus
Reference
BBBH183613
Expiry Date
01/01/01
Author
Neil BurtonAuthor
Neil BurtonSalary:
Negotiable
Location:
Lancing, West Sussex
Industry
Investment Management
Qualification
None specified
Market
Financial Services
Salary
£50,000 - £60,000
Job Discipline
Part Qualified & Transactional Finance
Contract Type:
Permanent
Description
A newly created position to join a Private Equity firm to assist with their growth within the Finance function.
Reference
BBBH183611
Expiry Date
01/01/01
Author
Thomas SteelAuthor
Thomas SteelSalary:
£28,000 - £30,000 per annum
Location:
Leeds, West Yorkshire
Industry
Business Services
Qualification
None specified
Market
Commerce & Industry
Salary
£30,000 - £35,000
Job Discipline
Part Qualified & Transactional Finance
Contract Type:
Permanent
Description
Purchase Ledger clerk - South Leeds
Reference
BBBH183605
Expiry Date
01/01/01
Author
Cameron WalshAuthor
Cameron WalshSalary:
£27,000 - £28,000 per annum
Location:
Chester, Cheshire
Industry
Business Services
Qualification
None specified
Market
Commerce & Industry
Salary
£25,000 - £30,000
Job Discipline
Part Qualified & Transactional Finance
Contract Type:
Permanent
Description
Accounts Assistant
Reference
BBBH183497
Expiry Date
01/01/01
Author
Glenn FyfeAuthor
Glenn FyfeSalary:
£40,000 - £55,000 per annum
Location:
London
Industry
Consumer & Retail
Qualification
Part qualified
Market
Commerce & Industry
Salary
£50,000 - £60,000
Job Discipline
Part Qualified & Transactional Finance
Contract Type:
Contract
Description
Seeking a VAT Analyst for a 6-month contract within a consumer retail business based in Central London.
Reference
JSM1747541
Expiry Date
01/01/01
Author
Jamie SmithAuthor
Jamie SmithSalary:
£50,000 - £60,000 per annum
Location:
London
Industry
Healthcare
Qualification
Part qualified
Market
Commerce & Industry
Salary
£60,000 - £70,000
Job Discipline
Part Qualified & Transactional Finance
Contract Type:
Contract
Description
Seeking a Finance Manager for a 3-month contract for a public sector organisation.
Reference
JSM174775
Expiry Date
01/01/01
Author
Jamie SmithAuthor
Jamie SmithSalary:
+ benefits
Location:
London
Industry
Private Equity
Qualification
Fully qualified
Market
Financial Services
Salary
£70,000 - £80,000
Job Discipline
Qualified Finance
Contract Type:
Permanent
Description
Fund Controller - Private Credit - Hybrid An excellent role working for a strong player in the Private Credit Fund sector, looking to hire a Fund Controller due to growth of their business.
Reference
BBBH183574
Expiry Date
01/01/01
Author
Paul RocheAuthor
Paul Roche